Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Panineria Nyc menu

17 dishes across 5 sections $10 to $20 Italian restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Panineria Nyc photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Panineria Nyc photo menu 1 Panineria Nyc photo menu 2 Panineria Nyc photo menu 3 Panineria Nyc photo menu 4 Panineria Nyc photo menu 5 Panineria Nyc photo menu 6 Panineria Nyc photo menu 7 Panineria Nyc photo menu 8 Panineria Nyc photo menu 9 Panineria Nyc photo menu 10

All Day - Limited Edition Sandwiches 7 dishes

  • Torre Del Greco US$19.00

    Organic Roasted Pork, Smoked Mozzarella, Sautéed Mushrooms, EVOO

  • Chicken Del Vesuvio US$21.00

    Chicken Cutlet, Smoked Mozzarella, Broccoli Rabe and Homemade Mayonnaise

  • Cremona Sandwich US$20.00

    Imported Mortadella, Organic Imported Burrata, crumbles pistachio from Sicily, Extra Virgin Olive Oil Contains nuts

  • Chicken Parm Sandwich US$18.00

    Organic Chicken Cutlet, Organic Tomato Sauce, Organic Fresh Mozzarella, Shaved Parmesan

  • Gotta Cheese US$15.00

    Goat cheese, Homemade Caramelized Onions, EVOO

  • Caterina's Grilled Chicken US$26.00

    Grilled Chicken, Organic Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, Homemade Pesto Sauce, Pistachio Crumble, Garlic Oil

  • 4 Cheese Lovers US$20.00

    Filled with Gorgonzola, Stracchino, Fontina, Shaved Parmesan. Add prosciutto for $3 for extra tastiness

All Day - Bakery 5 dishes

  • Bombolino - Italian Style Mini Donut US$4.00

    1 Italian donut small size

  • Homemade Bombolone - Italian Style Donuts US$6.00

    1 italian bombolone donut large size

  • Homemade Fluffly Onions Focaccia US$7.00

    Homemade Fluffly Onions Focaccia

  • Homemade Fluffly Potatoes And Rosemary Focaccia US$7.00

    Soft focaccia topped with thinly sliced potatoes and fresh rosemary.

  • Homemade Fluffly Tomato Focaccia US$7.00

    Soft, airy focaccia topped with tangy tomato sauce and a sprinkle of aromatic herbs.

All Day - Freshly made Sandwiches 15 dishes

  • Make Your Own Sandwich US$8.00

    Create your own delicious dream Sandwich

  • Diamante Sandwich US$13.00

    Spicy salame, provolone cheese PDO, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Alba Sandwich US$13.00

    Prosciutto Crudo Parma PDO, fontina cheese PDO, organic Italian truffle oil, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Paestum Sandwich US$13.00

    Prosciutto Crudo di Parma, Organic Fresh Mozzarella and E.V olive oil.

  • Parma Sandwich US$15.00

    Prosciutto Crudo Parma PDO, Stracchino fresh soft cheese and Organic Arugola

  • Portofino Sandwich US$14.00

    Prosciutto Cotto PDO, fontina cheese PDO, organic Italian fig mustard, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Bologna Sandwich US$13.00

    Mortadella PGI (contains pistachio), provolone cheese PDO, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Napoli Sandwich US$13.00

    Salame, provolone cheese PDO, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Americano Sandwich US$14.00

    Organic smoked Turkey, organic tomatoes, Italian Organic Mozzarella and EV Olive oil

  • The Vegan SANDWICH US$13.00

    Organic Sautéed Mushroom, Organic Arugula, Organic Dried Tomatoes

  • Sorrento Sandwich - Vegetarian US$13.00

    Organic fresh mozzarella PDO, organic tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, and homemade organic pesto sauce.

  • Capri Sandwich - Vegetarian US$13.00

    Organic fresh mozzarella, organic tomatoes, fresh basil and E.V. olive oil.

  • Sicilia Sandwich - Vegetarian US$14.00

    Organic fresh mozzarella PDO, organic tomatoes, organic artichoke sauce, and extra virgin olive oil

  • Valtellina Sandwich US$19.00

    Bresaola PGI, shaved parmigiano reggiano PDO, organic arugula and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Bread With Nutella US$8.00

    Bread with Italian Nutella

All Day - Special Sandwiches 10 dishes

  • Peppe SANDWICH US$17.00

    Prosciutto Crudo di Parma PDO, organic fresh mozzarella PDO, organic tomatoes, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Carciofo Sandwich US$19.00

    Prosciutto Cotto PDO, Fresh Mozzarella, Organic Tomatoes and organic artichoke sauce.

  • Amalfi Sandwich US$21.00

    Italian tuna in olive oil, organic arugula, organic tomatoes, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Olga SANDWICH US$17.00

    Prosciutto Cotto PDO, organic fresh mozzarella PDO, organic tomatoes, organic arugula and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Eggplant Parmigiana SANDWICH US$17.00

    Eggplant parmigiana with Mozzarella, tomato sauce and fresh basil ( Oven Baked ) Served on our fresh ciabatta bread

  • Vegetarian Burrata Sandwich US$18.00

    Organic Tomatoes, Organic Italian Burrata cheese, Organic Arugula, EVOO

  • MeatBalls Sandwich US$18.00

    Homemade 100% angus beef meatballs with tomato sauce served on our fresh Ciabatta Bread with Parmigiano Cheese and Fresh Arugula

  • Fresh Truffle Sandwich US$25.00

    Prosciutto Crudo di Parma PDO, Organic Mozzarella, Truffle and Mushrooms Cream, Organic Arugula and Truffle Oil

  • Burrata Sandwich US$21.00

    Organic Italian burrata, Prosciutto Crudo di Parma PDO, organic tomatoes, organic arugula and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Super Mario Sandwich US$22.00

    Prosciutto Crudo di Parma PDO, salame, mortadella PGI (contains pistachio), organic fresh mozzarella PDO and extra virgin olive oil.

All Day - Salads 6 dishes

  • Italian Tuna Salad US$22.00

    Mixed organic seasonal vegetables, organic cherry tomatoes, Italian tuna in extra virgin olive oil, and Himalayan pink salt.

  • Caprese Salad US$17.00

    Organic fresh mozzarella PDO, organic tomatoes, fresh basil, Homemade Pesto sauce, Himalayan pink salt, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Caesar Salad US$21.00

    Organic Romaine Lattuce, Italian shaved parmigiano cheese, homemade crispy croutons, Caesar dressing, Organic Grilled Chicken

  • Bresaola Salad US$19.00

    Bresaola PDO, Italian parmigiano cheese, organic arugula, Organic Cherry Tomatoes and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Chicken Cutlet Salad US$17.00

    Organic Mixed Green, Organic Cherry Tomatoes, Homemade Pesto Sauce, Organic Chicken Cutlet, Organic Shaved Parmesan, EVOO

  • Artichokes Salad US$17.00

    Organic mix green, Organic Cherry Tomatoes, Organic artichokes, Balsamic glaze, Extra virgin olive oil

All Day - Pasta Salads 5 dishes

  • Pasta Caprese Salad US$16.00

    Organic Italian pasta, organic cherry tomato, fresh basil, organic fresh mozzarella PDO, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Pasta Pesto Salad US$16.00

    Organic Italian pasta, organic homemade nut-free pesto sauce, Italian Parmigiano cheese, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Pasta Tuna Salad US$19.00

    Organic Italian pasta, Italian tuna in olive oil, organic cherry tomato, and extra virgin olive oil.

  • Pasta Artichoke Salad US$16.00

    Organic Italian pasta, organic fresh mozzarella PDO, organic cherry tomato, and Italian organic artichoke hearts.

  • Pasta Burrata Salad US$20.00

    Organic Italian pasta, organic Italian burrata PDO, organic arugula, organic cherry tomato, and extra virgin olive oil.

All Day - Starters and Soups 7 dishes

  • Homemade Grilled Garlic Bread With Mozzarella US$13.00

    Grilled seasoned Bread topped with melted Mozzarella

  • Homemade Garlic Bread US$4.00

    Grilled Garlic Bread With Italian Seasoning

  • Homemade Bechamel Truffle Sauce Dip Served With Garlic Bread US$15.00

    Homemade Bechamel with truffle patè dip. Served with garlic bread

  • Homemade Bolognese Sauce Dip Served With Garlic Bread US$15.00

    Beef bolognese dip sauce served with garlic bread

  • Homemade Spicy Tomato Sauce Dip Served With Garlic Bread US$15.00

    Spicy tomato dip served with garlic bread

  • Homemade Lentil Soup Served With Garlic Bread US$14.00

    Homemade lentil soup served with garlic bread

  • Homemade Garlic Bread With Smoked Mozzarella US$13.00

    Homemade bread with garlic butter and smoked mozzarella

All Day - Pasta, Lasagna and Main Dishes 14 dishes

  • Pasta With Tomato Sauce And Basil US$18.00

    Pasta with Tomato Sauce, Grated Parmesan and Basil

  • Homemade MeatBalls With Tomato Sauce Served With Garlic Bread US$17.00

    Homemade 100% angus beef meatballs with tomato sauce

  • Pasta With Homemade Pesto Sauce And Parmigiano US$19.00

    Pasta with House made organic pesto sauce, parmigiano, basil and EVOO

  • Pasta With Beef Meatballs And Tomato Sauce, Basil And Parmigiano US$20.00

    Pasta with Beef Meatballs and Tomato Sauce, basil and parmigiano

  • Pasta With Bolognese Sauce US$19.00

    Homemade beef bolognese sauce and Parmesan cheese

  • Pasta Arrabbiata Sauce And Burrata US$22.00

    Pasta Arrabiata Sauce and Burrata cheese

  • Homemade Lasagna With Bolognese Sauce US$19.00

    Homemade Lasagna with beef Bolognese Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmigiano and Tomato Sauce.

  • Eggplant Parmigiana Main US$19.00

    Eggplant parmigiana with Mozzarella, tomato sauce and fresh basil ( Oven Baked )

  • Pasta With Truffle And Mushrooms US$21.00

    Pasta with Homemade Bechamel sauce, sautéed mushroom and Truffle patè

  • Pasta Rosa US$19.00

    Pasta with Tomato Sauce, Organic Ricotta Cheese and Parmesan Cheese

  • Chicken Pesto Pasta US$30.00

    Pasta with Grilled Chicken, Homemade Bechamel Sauce, Homemade Pesto, Organic Onions, Sautéed Mushroom, Organic Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese

  • Rigatoni Mamma Anna US$22.00

    Rigatoni Pasta Cooked With Baked Eggplant And Ricotta Cheese

  • Chicken Cordon Bleu US$19.00

    Chicken Cutlet, Organic Mozzarella, Imported Italian Cooked Ham. Topped with Arugola

  • Rigatoni 4 Cheeses US$22.00

    Rigatoni pasta with Bechamel Sauce, Smoked Cheese, Stracchino, Parmesan and Gorgonzola

All Day - Cheese by Weight 5 dishes

  • Parmigiano Reggiano - Half Pound US$19.99

    1/2 lb.

  • Fontina PDO - Half Pound US$12.99

    1/2 lb.

  • Organic Fresh Mozzarella US$12.99

    1/2 lb.

  • Provolone PDO - Half Pound US$12.99

    1/2 lb.

  • Organic Ricotta Cheese 1 Pound US$20.00

    Creamy and smooth organic ricotta cheese, perfect for adding to your favorite Italian dishes. One pound.

All Day - Meat by Weight 7 dishes

  • 1/2 Lb Organic Smoked Turkey US$15.99

    Organic Smoked Turkey

  • 1/2 Lb. Mortadella US$12.99

    1/2 lb.

  • 1/2 Lb. Salame US$16.99

    1/2 lb.

  • 1/2 Lb. Spicy Salame US$16.99

    1/2 lb.

  • 1/2 Lb. Prosciutto Crudo Di Parma PDO US$19.99

    1/2 lb.

  • 1/2 Lb. Prosciutto Cotto PDO US$19.99

    1/2 lb.

  • 1/2 Lb. Bresaola US$24.99

    1/2 lb.

All Day - Desserts 10 dishes

  • Cannolo US$2.50

    Filled with sweetened Italian ricotta cheese cream.

  • Bombolino - Italian Style Mini Donut US$4.00

    1 small Italian donut

  • Homemade Bombolone - Italian Style Donuts US$7.00

    1italian bombolone donut

  • Bread With Nutella US$8.00

    Bread with Italian Nutella

  • Homemade Grandmother's Cake US$12.00

    Homemade Grandmother's Cake with lemon custard cream

  • Homemade Tiramisu' US$10.00

    Homemade Tiramisu'

  • Traditional Italian Croissant US$4.95

    Homemade croissant

  • Homemade Italian Ricotta Cheesecake US$9.00

    Baked cake filled with ricotta cheese

  • Pistachios Croissant US$11.00

    Homemade croissant filled with pistachios cream and pistachios crumble

  • Chocolate Heaven Without Flour US$12.00

    Rich, dense chocolate cake made without flour, topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar.

All Day - Breads 1 dishes

  • Bread US$6.00

    Fresh Baked

All Day - Coffee Hot or Iced 14 dishes

  • Cappuccino Hot -16oz US$5.99

    Two shots of Italian espresso with foam milk

  • Latte Hot - 16oz US$5.99

    One shot of Italian espresso and milk

  • Espresso US$2.99

    Original italian espresso coffee.

  • Double Espresso US$3.99

    Original Italian espresso

  • Organic Hot Chocolate - 16oz US$5.99

    Homemade hot chocolate

  • Americano Hot - 16oz US$4.99

    Original americano coffee

  • Macchiato US$3.99

    1 shot of espresso and a little bit of foam at the top

  • Mocha US$4.95

    Hot chocolate and 2 shots of Italian espresso

  • Hot Tea - 16oz US$3.99

    English breakfast tea

  • Signature Nutella Marocchino 12oz US$5.99

    2 shot of Italian espresso, foam milk, and imported nutella

  • Iced Americano - 16oz US$4.99

    Original iced americano coffee

  • Iced Cappuccino - 16oz US$5.99

    2 hots of espresso, foam milk iced

  • Iced Latte - 16oz US$5.99

    One shot of espresso, milk iced

  • Pistacho Coffee 12oz US$9.60

    Contains nuts. 2 shots of espresso, foam milk, pistacho cream and pistachos chopped on top

All Day - Soft Drink 14 dishes

  • Water Bottle US$2.00

    Water Bottle

  • Coca Cola US$2.50

    Coca Cola Can

  • Ginger Ale US$2.50

    Ginger Ale

  • Diet Coca Cola US$2.50

    Diet Coke can

  • San Pellegrino Sparkling - 250ml US$3.75

    Glass Bottle

  • Sicilian Lemonade Soda (Red Orange) US$4.50

    Original blood orange drink from sicily

  • Sicilian Lemonade Soda (Lemon) US$4.50

    Original Limonata from sicily

  • Homemade Fresh Squeezed Lemonade US$6.00

    Homemade

  • Homemade Fresh Squeezed Strawberry Lemonade US$6.00

    Homemade

  • Homemade Fresh Squeezed Peach Lemonade US$6.00

    Homemade

  • Homemade Iced Tea US$6.00

    Homemade

  • Orange Juice US$6.00

    Fresh

  • San Pellegrino Sparkling - 1L US$8.00

    Glass Bottle

  • Acqua Panna - 1L - Glass Bottle US$8.00

    Glass Bottle

All Day - Groceries, Sauces and More 19 dishes

  • Glaze Balsamic Vinegar Of Modena 500ml Varvello US$15.00

    Imported from Italy

  • Italian Coffee Beans - 2lb US$40.00

    Imported whole Italian coffee beans, typically used for making espresso or drip coffee, offering an authentic Italian coffee experience.

  • De Cecco Lasagna Pasta Sheets - 1lb US$6.00

    Crafted in Italy, these lasagna pasta sheets are slow-dried for superior quality, ideal for layering in your favorite lasagna recipes.

  • Del Verde Rigatoni Pasta - 5lb US$30.00

    Dry, tube-shaped pasta typically used in hearty Italian dishes. Ideal for absorbing robust sauces and perfect for a variety of recipes.

  • Artichoke Marinated In Extra Virgin Olive Oil US$40.00

    Pasta with cherry tomatoes, mozzarella, and a basil garnish.

  • Organic Italian Fig Jam US$15.00

    Made from 100% fresh organic figs, this Italian fig jam offers a naturally sweet and rich flavor.

  • Black Truffle And Champignons Cream - 14.11 Floor US$30.00

    Smooth blend of earthy black truffles and champignons, creating a rich and savory puree perfect for enhancing various dishes.

  • Organic Truffle Oil - 8.75 Fl Oz US$30.00

    Organic truffle oil typically includes truffle-infused olive oil. Ideal for drizzling over pasta, risotto, or salads to add a subtle truffle flavor.

  • Lay's Chips US$2.50

    Crispy and salty potato chips, perfect for snacking.

  • Miss Vickie’s BBQ Chips US$3.60

    Kettle-cooked potato chips with a smoky barbecue flavor.

  • Balsamic Vinegar Of Modena- Varvello Brand- Organic 500ml US$15.00

    Certified organic balsamic vinegar from Modena, offering a rich, balanced flavor ideal for enhancing salads, marinades, and various dishes. 500ml bottle.

  • Pomegrade Cider Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic- 500ml US$15.00

    Organic pomegranate cider vinegar, raw and unfiltered, with the mother. 500ml.

  • Apple Cider With Honey Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic- 500ml US$15.00

    Organic apple cider vinegar with honey, raw and unfiltered, 500ml.

  • Prosecco Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic- 500ml US$20.00

    Made from organic Prosecco grapes, this Prosecco vinegar offers a crisp and tangy flavor, ideal for dressings and marinades. 500ml bottle.

  • Pinot Grigio Wine Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic- 500ml US$20.00

    Barrel-aged Pinot Grigio wine vinegar with a delicate, balanced acidity, offering a refined touch to salads and marinades. Organic, 500ml.

  • Barolo Wine Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic- 500ml US$25.00

    Aged Barolo wine vinegar with rich, robust flavor, crafted from organic ingredients. Ideal for enhancing salads, marinades, and sauces. 500ml bottle.

  • Rosè Wine Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic- 250ml US$25.00

    Rosè wine vinegar with a delicate balance of acidity and sweetness, made from organic ingredients, 250ml.

  • High Density Balsamic Vinegar IGP- Varvello Brand Organic -250ml US$25.00

    Rich, organic balsamic vinegar from Modena, aged to enhance deep, complex flavors, ideal for salads, marinades, and gourmet dishes.

  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil 1Liter US$22.00

    A blend of 100% Italian and Greek extra virgin olive oils, ideal for enhancing gourmet recipes.

All Day - Limited Edition Filled Croissant 1 dishes

  • Pistacchio Croissant US$11.00

    Homemade croissant filled and topped with pistachios cream and pistachios crumble

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

If you're looking for an authentic Italian dining experience in the heart of New York City, Panineria NYC is the place to be. Located at 9 E 8th St, New York, NY 10003, this charming spot brings the warmth of Italy to the bustling streets of Manhattan. The vibe at Panineria NYC is everything you'd expect from a cozy Italian restaurant - welcoming, casual, and laid-back, perfect for any occasion. Whether you're popping in for a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal, you can choose to dine in or take advantage of their outdoor seating for a relaxed alfresco experience.

The restaurant offers a variety of service options to suit your needs, including curbside pickup, delivery (with no-contact options), and takeaway, making it super convenient for those on the go. On-site, you'll find a great selection of comfort foods and quick bites, ranging from small plates to a vibrant salad bar. If you're in the mood for a drink, Panineria NYC has you covered with options like cocktails, beer, and wine. For those looking for a bit of extra fun, the happy-hour drinks are a fantastic choice.

Vegetarian options are available, so everyone can find something to enjoy. The menu includes delicious options like hearty sandwiches, fresh salads, and satisfying small plates. Whether you're grabbing a quick coffee, enjoying a leisurely lunch, or sipping a glass of wine with friends, the atmosphere is always warm and inviting. It’s an ideal spot to unwind after a busy day in the city, indulge in comfort food, or try out some unique Italian-inspired dishes. If you're in the neighborhood, Panineria NYC should definitely be on your list!

Other menus in New York

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All New York listings
Call Menu Directions